It Doesn't Have To Be Right…

… it just has to sound plausible

More Catching Up With The Challenge


October’s book for my 2008 Reading Challenge was Ford Madox Ford’s The Good Soldier. Like many of the books I chose for my challenge, I knew almost nothing about it. I knew it existed; I’d probably seen mention of it in various places, not to mention catching sight of it on the “classics” shelves in my local Waterstone’s. But I knew nothing about Ford – who he was, what part he played in English literature, or even what was the general reputation of The Good Soldier. And that’s one reason why I chose it. The other reason is that it’s a slim novel – I’d have liked to try a James Joyce novel, and I have a copy of Ulysses… but it’s huge (I also own Anthony Burgess’ Here Comes Everybody, his study of, although there’s little point in reading about, unless I’ve read Joyce, Joyce, Joyce*).

However, The Good Soldier

The novel is set just prior to World War I and is narrated by John Dowell, a wealthy American mostly resident in Europe. He and his wife, Florence, spend several months each year at Nauheim, a spa in Germany. While there they’re chiefly in the company of another couple, Edward and Leonora Ashburnham, who are English. Edward is the good soldier of the title. Dowell’s narrative skips about in time, describing incidents in no particular order from the decade or so during which the Dowells and Ashburnhams are friends. What Dowell does not initially reveal – although it’s later clear that he knows it at the time he is recounting the story – is that Edward is a philanderer and having an affair with Florence. And she has also had a succession of lovers – beginning with a blue-collar thing, Jimmy, whom she was sleeping with when she married Dowell.

As The Good Soldier progresses, Dowell reveals more and more of the peculiar dynamics between the two couples. When Florence learns that Edward has fallen in love with Nancy Rufford, the ward of Edward and Leonora, she commits suicide. Edward also commits suicide later, when Leonora sabotages Nancy’s burgeoning love for him.

Ford originally titled the novel The Saddest Story, and Dowell repeatedly describes the story as the saddest he knows. Perhaps too often. I can understand how a chronologically non-linear narrative might have been seen as something new and astonishing in 1915, when the book was first published, but it’s an unremarkable technique nowadays. The same is also true of using an unreliable narrator (if you’ve read anything by Gene Wolfe, you’ll be only too familiar with unreliable narrators). Which means that much of what’s interesting about The Good Soldier is no longer the case. The book does, however, give a good indication of what life was like for wealthy Edwardians – for example, Edward is almost sent to prison for kissing a maid on a train. That “consorting with the lower classes” was a crime then seems completely bizarre.

Ford’s maintenance of Dowell’s voice throughout The Good Soldier is impressive. Not once does he let his character slip. Unfortunately, far too much is told rather than shown. I suppose in part that’s the nature of a recounted narrative. It’s also perhaps the fashion of the time. But it reads somewhat distant to a modern reader.

In all, I find it hard to consider The Good Soldier as good as its reputation. I enjoyed reading it, and it’s a clever evocation of Edwardian England. But its two innovations – a non-linear narrative and an unreliable narrator – are neither as remarkable as they were in 1915. It’s by no means a difficult read, although it is difficult to care about the characters – which is hardly unsurprising, given that they’re hardly pleasant people. “Good people”, perhaps, but not pleasant. Having said that, I think I rate The Good Soldier higher than some of the books I’ve read during my challenge. But The Jewel in the Crown remains the highwater mark, and A Question of Upbringing a distant second.

* to spoof Burgess’ infamous: “He breathed baffingly on him, for no banquet would serve, because of the known redolence of onions, onions, onions” in Enderby Outside.

8 thoughts on “More Catching Up With The Challenge

  1. Found GOOD SOLDIER just too cool and uninvolving for my tastes. The writing assured, without a spark of humanity present. No scenes stand out, few vestiges of the story remain in my memory. Technically sound but doesn’t pass the “so what?” test…

  2. I love the Good Soldier, and I’m here to stand up for cool and uninvolving art: Kubrick! Nabokov! Rothko! Hurrah!This is a good review. Although whilst I think you’re right to say that the technical innovations seem a little old hat nowadays, I’d say what matters is the extent to which Ford is able to articulate his interest in emotional complexity and repression via this method. Which, it seems to me, he does. There are few better portraits of the contorpulations emotional repression wreaks upon ordinary subjectivity than this novel.Also your ‘Joyce, Joyce, Joyce’ repetition, to match Burgess, needs to be something like: ‘He felt a certain apprehension discussing, never having read, on account of the alleged difficulty of Joyce, Joyce, Joyce.’Although, looking at that, on second thoughts: maybe not.

  3. (What I mean is that the first clause of your sentence, since it doesn’t relate to Joyce, throws the rest off kilter. Not that my version was better, I concede).

  4. Point taken on the Burgess line.I’ve not tried Nabokov, although I’ve sort of been meaning to for a while. But, you know, huge pile of books I really do want to read… Which does make me wonder why I even bothered to challenge myself to read a classic novel each month I’d not read before. Still, it did introduce me to Paul Scott’s fiction, so it hasn’t been a total dead loss.Speaking of reviews, The Good Soldier was a doddle compared to Lexicon Urthus – I mean, reviewing a dictionary…

  5. re: Nabokov. People will tell you that Lolita and Pale Fire are masterpieces, and people won’t be wrong. But the book that first made me fall in love with N (beautiful, hilarious, chilly, moving, profound) is Pnin. It’s 140 pages, or so. I recommend.

  6. Ta. I’ll bung it on the wants list.

  7. Pingback: The 2009 Reading Challenge « It Doesn't Have To Be Right…

  8. Pingback: I am not a book blogger… « It Doesn't Have To Be Right…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.